by george!

Freedom-crushing automobile-hating authoritarian

Conservative columnist George Will wrote a piece for right-wing comic Newsweek recently attacking President Obama’s support for high-speed rail.

Now, if Georgie’s main concern was cost, then you might say, ‘okay, that’s an argument’.

But no, as Steve Benen (Washington Monthly) put it, the column, which “featured a variety of errors of fact and judgment”, suggested that “liberals support high-speed rail (as) part of some elaborate, freedom-crushing, Ayn-Rand-inspired conspiracy.”


Okay, deep breath, here are a couple of extracts:

George Will: High Speed to Insolvency – Why liberals love trains.

“Generations hence, when the river of time has worn this presidency’s importance to a small, smooth pebble in the stream of history, people will still marvel that its defining trait was a mania for high-speed rail projects. This disorder illuminates the progressive mind…..

… Only an administration blinkered by ideology would persist … the real reason for progressives’ passion for trains is their goal of diminishing Americans’ individualism in order to make them more amenable to collectivism.

To progressives, the best thing about railroads is that people riding them are not in automobiles, which are subversive of the deference on which progressivism depends …. automobiles encourage people to think they – unsupervised, untutored, and unscripted – are masters of their fates. The automobile encourages people in delusions of adequacy, which make them resistant to government by experts who know what choices people should make…….”

I know, I know.

Paul Krugman, who described the column as “truly bizarre”, made a similar point to Benen: “….it’s amazing to see Will – who is not a stupid man – embracing the sinister progressives-hate-your-freedom line, more or less right out of Atlas Shrugged; with the extra irony, of course, that John Galt’s significant other ran, well, a railroad.”

So, you’d imagine Georgie would disagree with this columnist who, in 2001 (after 9/11), wrote:

” ….Americans are impatient problem-solvers, so here are three things that should be done, the doing of which will assuage any sense the nation is having trouble gaining traction in the tasks at hand.

…..Third, build high-speed rail service.

…..A government study concludes that for trips of 500 miles or less – a majority of flights; 40 percent are of 300 miles or less – automotive travel is as fast or faster than air travel, door to door. Columnist Robert Kuttner sensibly says that fact strengthens the case for high-speed trains. If such trains replaced air shuttles in the Boston-New York-Washington corridor, Kuttner says that would free about 60 takeoff and landing slots per hour.”

Who wrote this? A liberal trying to take away your automobile freedom? Eh, no. Ready for this? Those are Georgie’s very own words, as reported by Sarah Goodyear (Grist).

Benen: “I don’t care that Will changed his mind; I care that he casually dismissed the substance of the debate in order to make the truly stupid case that high-speed rail is part of a liberal crusade to “diminish Americans’ individualism in order to make them more amenable to collectivism.”

On the merits, he was right the first time. To agree with Will circa 2001 is not to be a freedom-crushing authoritarian.”


So, Georgie was an enthusiastic supporter of high-speed rail….until he found himself on the same side of the issue as President Obama??

The amazing part is that this guy displays sense, occasionally – as Krugman said, “he is not a stupid man”, he has supported the President at times and has attacked the extremes of the GOP/Tea Party.

So what’s this nonsense and hypocrisy all about??

11 Responses to “by george!”

  1. 1 Anonymous
    March 5, 2011 at 7:39 pm

    And this is the same man who lambastes Mike Huckabee. They all do the same things in slightly different days. Go figure.

  2. 2 Hachikō
    March 5, 2011 at 7:40 pm

    George [w]ill continue to prove himself to be the ass that he is. He can’t help himself. That’s why I don’t pay any attention to anything he writes/says even if it’s something that SEEMS supportive of the president and/or his policies.

  3. 3 V C prezOfan2
    March 5, 2011 at 7:41 pm

    “Generations hence, when the river of time has worn this presidency’s importance to a small, smooth pebble in the stream of history,…

    You wish, Georgie, oh you wish! Is this your prayer? :mrgreen:

  4. March 5, 2011 at 7:56 pm

    I think it’s important to remember that for many trips, the choice would not be between trains and cars. The choice is between trains and airplanes. It would be hard to make the argument that trains are more collectivist and destructive of individual freedom than planes, which require you to take off your shoes and submit to three different government inspectors before you can even board.


  5. 6 Sue in Minnesota
    March 5, 2011 at 8:25 pm

    Hypocrisy aside, Will is such a priggish excuse for a man.

    Generations hence, where stands a monument in recognition of President Obama, a truly great and beloved man, memory of George Will, will be like dust in the wind…..gone, baby, gone.

  6. 7 cat48
    March 5, 2011 at 8:51 pm

    Sue, I agree, Barack Obama, will always be important in History books, if only because he was the first black president! He’ll also get a lot of attention yearly during Black History month. I happen to think he’ll be known for more than that; George, not so much!

  7. 8 stylishgurl
    March 5, 2011 at 9:07 pm

    George Will is an intellectually dishonest bafoon…. the end! *side eye*

  8. 9 Lovepolitics2008
    March 5, 2011 at 9:26 pm

    My goodness, these conservatives are losing their minds. SERIOUSLY !

  9. 10 Asher in Boston
    March 5, 2011 at 9:55 pm

    Poor George, my advice to you is just go jump into a lake. What I mean is, GET LOST AND SHUT THE EFF UP.

  10. 11 Sonjia Duncan
    March 6, 2011 at 8:04 am

    I live on the east coast or as one of my sons says the right coast and high speed travel is long overdue. Still living the Jetson image of the future. To be able to catch the train and have the freedom to travel on day trips is individual freedom. I resent the changes and restrictions of air travel. I travel for almost 30 years and experience the changes that were not progressive but regressive to a large extent. Give me high speed trains so the it is a means to getting where I want to go and the destination is the focus.

Comments are currently closed.







Enter your email address to receive notifications of new posts by email.



RSS Obama White House.gov

  • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.

RSS WH Tumblr

  • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.

RSS Steve Benen

  • President Biden and first lady set to visit Buffalo
  • 'Ukrainians want to go home': Refugees begin heading home in droves
  • Biden and Jeff Bezos spar over tweet about inflation
  • Steve Kornacki: Governor and Senate race in Pa. could have tag-team effect
  • 'White supremacy is a global terror threat': Head of ADL calls on Biden for anti-hate strategy



Blog Stats

  • 43,232,240 hits

%d bloggers like this: